| UFC 309: Jones vs. Miocic | Bo Nickal | 1062 →1080(+18) | Paul Craig | 1036 →1017(-19) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC 301: Pantoja vs. Erceg | Caio Borralho | 1098 →1119(+21) | Paul Craig | 1056 →1036(-20) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Allen vs. Craig | Brendan Allen | 1158 →1176(+18) | Paul Craig | 1073 →1056(-17) | Middleweight | Loss | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Aspinall vs. Tybura | Paul Craig | 1048 →1073(+25) | Andre Muniz | 1087 →1062(-25) | Middleweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 283: Teixeira vs. Hill | Johnny Walker | 1039 →1064(+25) | Paul Craig | 1073 →1048(-25) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Blaydes vs. Aspinall | Volkan Oezdemir | 1025 →1049(+24) | Paul Craig | 1097 →1073(-24) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Volkov vs. Aspinall | Paul Craig | 1075 →1097(+22) | Nikita Krylov | 1054 →1032(-22) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC 263: Adesanya vs. Vettori 2 | Paul Craig | 1053 →1075(+22) | Jamahal Hill | 1045 →1023(-22) | Light Heavyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 255: Figueiredo vs. Perez | Paul Craig | 1026 →1053(+27) | Mauricio Rua | 1091 →1064(-27) | Light Heavyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Whittaker vs. Till | Paul Craig | 1003 →1026(+23) | Gadzhimurad Antigulov | 998 →975(-23) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Blachowicz vs. Jacare | Mauricio Rua | 1073 →1073 | Paul Craig | 1003 →1003 | Light Heavyweight | draw
draw | S-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Rodriguez vs. Stephens | Paul Craig | 982 →1003(+21) | Vinicius Moreira | 954 →933(-21) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Ngannou vs. Dos Santos | Alonzo Menifield | 1023 →1044(+21) | Paul Craig | 1003 →982(-21) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Barboza vs. Gaethje | Paul Craig | 979 →1003(+24) | Kennedy Nzechukwu | 1000 →975(-25) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Dos Santos vs. Tuivasa | Jimmy Crute | 1000 →1023(+23) | Paul Craig | 1002 →979(-23) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Werdum vs. Volkov | Paul Craig | 978 →1002(+24) | Magomed Ankalaev | 1000 →975(-25) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Nelson vs. Ponzinibbio | Khalil Rountree Jr. | 982 →1006(+24) | Paul Craig | 1002 →978(-24) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 209: Woodley vs. Thompson 2 | Tyson Pedro | 1021 →1044(+23) | Paul Craig | 1026 →1002(-24) | Light Heavyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC on FOX: VanZant vs. Waterson | Paul Craig | 1000 →1026(+26) | Henrique da Silva | 1045 →1019(-26) | Light Heavyweight | Win | SUB |
